THE SURPRISING GIFT OF DOUBT

Use Uncertainty to Become the Exceptional Leader You Are Meant to Be

The Surprising Gift of Doubt covers

Are you a high-performing leader haunted by self-doubt?

 

What if that doubt isn’t a weakness, but your greatest asset? What if it’s actually signaling you’re on the verge of a leadership breakthrough?

Your Doubt is Telling You Something Important

Most leaders experience a moment when they realize they don’t have all the answers. You’ve likely hit milestone after milestone, with people looking to you for direction. Yet inside, you feel like you’re just making it up as you go along.

This doubt isn’t a signal to retreat—it’s an invitation to advance into what Marc calls “Quadrant 3 Leadership,” where you’ll discover:

  • How to turn uncertainty into your leadership superpower
  • A practical framework to find your authentic leadership voice
  • Tools to create leadership systems built specifically for you, not forcing you into someone else’s mold
  • A path from feeling “broken” to recognizing the wonderful gift you are to your organization

Beyond Copying Others or Following Gurus

Leadership isn’t about mimicking others or following rigid formulas. It’s about developing your own authentic leadership style based on your unique:

Hardwiring

Discover your natural abilities and strengths instead of fighting against them

Identity

Uncover and reshape the stories that determine how you show up as a leader

Goals

Clarify what truly matters to you and your organization to drive focused action

In The Surprising Gift of Doubt, Marc guides you on this journey, showing you how to create the leadership approach that’s authentically yours.

For Leaders Ready to Move Beyond Impostor Syndrome

This book is your roadmap if you’re:

  • A CEO or executive director feeling the pressure of leadership isolation
  • A rising leader preparing for your next career step
  • A board member or volunteer who’s stepped into leadership
  • Anyone who’s experienced that nagging voice suggesting “you’re not good enough”

What Others Are Saying

“In a world promising magic formulas and 3 steps to success, in The Surprising Gift of Doubt, Marc Pitman delivers what leaders actually need: a process and tools to discover your inner truth, allowing you to lead with sincerity, confidence and effectiveness. Rather than running from doubt, you will see it for what it is: the key to your own strength and point of view as a leader.”

Pamela Slim

author of Body of Work

“The Surprising Gift of Doubt is an engaging read full of practical advice and tools that will help you on your leadership journey. Marc deftly and confidently leads readers through the hard, necessary work of understanding themselves and the unique contributions they can make both in their organizations and their personal lives.”

Kristen Hadeed

author of Permission to Screw Up

“A massively effective framework for self-awareness and leadership development that is practical, approachable, and actually doable. Bravo!”

Jay Baer

founder of Convince & Convert and author of Hug Your Haters

Order Now!

And begin your Quadrant 3 Leadership Journey!

Available in print, ebook, and now as an audiobook narrated by Marc with exclusive bonus content!

Support Independent Booksellers
Bookshop Logo
Surprising Gift of Doubt audiobook on Audible
Amazon Logo
BN Logo
Chapters Indigo Logo

Want copies for you entire leadership team?

Bulk discounts are available through Porchlight Books

Porchlight Logo
“In The Surprising Gift of Doubt, Marc Pitman offers a must-read road map for leadership that focuses on embracing doubt as a catalyst for change and building confidence. Marc shows us how to move beyond traditional leadership practices and unlock our organizations’ full potential by bringing emotional intelligence to the forefront. An empathetic and experienced leader himself, Marc takes you on a journey through the stages of leadership, empowering you to build custom routines and curriculums to bring your mission statement into action.”
Alison Stratten

co-author of UnMarketing, The Book of Business Awesome/UnAwesome, QR Codes Kill Kittens, UnBranding, UnSelling and The Jackass Whisperer

“Leaders know that reinvention is a constant process of learning and growing. The Surprising Gift of Doubt provides a powerful operating manual that will help you – whether you’re an entrepreneur or an intrapreneur – tap into the greatness inside of you and truly empower others.”
Dorie Clark

author of Reinventing You and executive education faculty, Duke University Fuqua School of Business

“Give a growth gift to yourself. The Surprising Gift of Doubt helps bring clarity to our leadership mindset. Marc’s engaging speaking comes through in this leadership tome.”
Jeremiah Owyang

Tech Analyst

Order Now!

And begin your Quadrant 3 Leadership Journey!

Doubt Icon
FAQ: “The Surprising Gift of Doubt”

Question Icon
What is “The Surprising Gift of Doubt” about?

This book helps leaders reframe self-doubt as a signal of growth rather than a flaw to eliminate. Marc A. Pitman guides readers to see doubt as a turning point—an invitation to lead with deeper confidence and clarity rooted in their unique strengths.

Question Icon
Who is this book for?

The book is written for leaders who have achieved some success but feel stuck, burned out, or like they’re secretly faking it. It’s especially useful for executives, nonprofit professionals, entrepreneurs, and coaches seeking more sustainable, authentic leadership.

Question Icon
Do readers need to have read Marc’s other books first?

Not at all. This book stands on its own. However, readers familiar with Ask Without Fear! or Marc’s coaching work will recognize his signature clarity, empathy, and practical encouragement.

Question Icon
Is this a typical step-by-step leadership manual?

No. Rather than offering a rigid formula, The Surprising Gift of Doubt introduces a flexible framework—Marc’s “Four Quadrants of Leadership”—that adapts to each reader’s stage of development.

Question Icon
What’s the “surprise” in the title?

The surprise is that doubt—so often seen as a problem—is actually a powerful signal that a leader is ready to grow. Marc shows how embracing this discomfort can unlock leadership breakthroughs and renewed confidence.

Question Icon
How is this different from other leadership books or trainings?

Most leadership books focus on tactics. Marc goes deeper, helping readers trust their wiring, understand their motivation, and develop their own leadership style. The book blends self-awareness, emotional intelligence, and practical tools.

Question Icon
Is this a good pick for leadership teams or book clubs?

Yes. Many teams and leadership cohorts use this book as a shared resource. Its self-reflective exercises and conversational tone make it highly effective for group discussions and retreats.

Question Icon
Is the content more personal growth or professional development?

Both. While rooted in leadership, the book is deeply personal. It encourages readers to explore their identity, motivation, and values—not just their skills or performance.

Question Icon
Can it be used as a coaching tool?

Absolutely. Coaches, consultants, and managers frequently use the Four Quadrants and Integrity Model to help clients or team members move through periods of doubt and emerge as more grounded, effective leaders.

Question Icon
Where can readers or organizations learn more?

More resources and speaking inquiries are available at ConcordLeadershipGroup.com, or by reaching out to Marc directly.

The Surprising Gift of Doubt covers

“This book fills the gap between being named a leader and truly performing like one.”

Cara Brookins

author of Rise: How a House Built a Family & Unstuck: End Procrastination Using the Ancient Psychology Behind How-to Videos

Which Leadership Style are YOU?

It only takes 2-3 minutes!

Exit Icon
Leadership style - Charismatic